Born in the wrong era? No. There is no wrong era.

the best is yet to come

20060524

 

part two of manga ethics: manga vs anime. manga wins

manga is when an author finally decides to materialize his imagination by transferring his ideas onto paper. hence how characters behave, look and how the story progresses will be at it's purest because it was the author who penned it down.
the only things that we cannot imagine will be the colour of things and the voices of the characters, well, actually...colours can be seen on the cover and the tone of their voices can be inferred from the font used...but nvm..
lots of people tell me that anime is better than manga because things actually MOVE.
well maybe.
i disagree but then again it depends on what people look out for. some people want to see the action of moving pictures.
i don't particularly care for that.
the problem with anime is that it has undergone the influence of many other people apart from the author. hence its manifestation will be a corrupted one in the sense that it was not as the author had originally imagined.
the director will decide how the scenes will progress, the voice actors, how the characters sound and feel, the animators, how the people look and move, the producer, the quality of the aformentioned and the resemblance to the original.
unless of course the author does all these roles and insists on replicating what he has in his mind. in such a case then purity would be retained.
or there never was a manga and the writers created the anime right from their head working as or alongside the director..these are rare cases where there was no manga but the creators just went straight to animation...if i am not wrong, i think ~Here and Then, Now and There~ is one such anime, and an excellant one at that.
otherwise, it is just a matter of how close the anime is to the manga.
because of these views, manga still reigns as top on my list over anime.
the next issue under scrutiny would then be my view on scanlations...

Comments: Post a Comment



<< Home

Archives

200602   200603   200604   200605   200606   200607   200608   200609   200610   200611   200612   200701   200702   200703   200704   200705   200706   200707   200708   200709   200710   200711   200712   200801   200803   200805   200806   200807   200808   200810   200811   200812   200901   200902   200904   200905   200906   200907   200908   200909   200910   200912   201002   201003   201007   201008   201009   201010   201011   201012   201101   201102   201104   201105   201106   201108   201109   201110   201111   201112   201203   201204   201205   201211   201302  

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?