Born in the wrong era? No. There is no wrong era.

the best is yet to come

20060620

 

manga ethics part 3: say 'no' to spoilers

scanlations.
sigh, the contoversial issue...
anyone who has spoken to me personally about this will know that i am not very fond of scanlations.
meaning, i do not particularly approve of going to the net and downloading the latest chapter of manga in english and reading it without paying a cent.
why?
cos it's in english. or maybe german, or spanish, or some other western language...but the author never had that in mind, he wrote in japanese, thought in japanese. by scanlating, other people would interpret what he meant at times and then translate it into their language.
while i approve of the fact that people are spreading the series, i still feel that the original language is best, with languages closer to it as better alternatives. like chinese.
of course i am not out of this because i cannot read japanese, so i'll have to settle for chinese, and really i am basically reading printed scanlations, but i think i am at least reading something legalised.
maybe i am jealous that people are getting what took me so hard to get by saving and waiting for publishing and ending up lagging alot anyhow. maybe i am. but i believe in the tradition of comics and books, manga was meant to be held in your hands, to be brought around, not to be read off a mere computer screen. depending on electricity to read it...when comics are available to you, buy them, that's why they are published. buy and share them. say no to scanlations.
what's worse?
when people read scanlations and know the latest progress of the story, they go about and tell others who read the slower published manga about what has happened, spoiling the story, often against the will of the victim.
terrible.
if u want to know, and can't wait, go ahead and read scanlations at the cost of your honour, but don't go and spoil it for the rest of us who wish to follow the natural course of things, and feel the joy of experiencing progressive revelation.
ummm, my thoughts are a bit disjointed, maybe i lazy to think to transfer to screen cos of the bad experiencs i had in the past...
but anyway, this wraps up the third and final part of this series on manga ethics.
thanks to anybody to bothered to read these articles.

Comments: Post a Comment



<< Home

Archives

200602   200603   200604   200605   200606   200607   200608   200609   200610   200611   200612   200701   200702   200703   200704   200705   200706   200707   200708   200709   200710   200711   200712   200801   200803   200805   200806   200807   200808   200810   200811   200812   200901   200902   200904   200905   200906   200907   200908   200909   200910   200912   201002   201003   201007   201008   201009   201010   201011   201012   201101   201102   201104   201105   201106   201108   201109   201110   201111   201112   201203   201204   201205   201211   201302  

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?